Not so close, after all
NY Times reports (registration required):
KIRKLAND, Wash., Nov. 28 (AP) - In a rare admission of error by the National Football League, the Seattle Seahawks received word on Monday that the referee Larry Nemmers had erred Sunday on both of the Giants' touchdowns in Seattle's 24-21 overtime victory."There were mistakes that were made," said Seattle Coach Mike Holmgren, one of eight men on the league's competition committee, which oversees rules and game operations.
The N.F.L. said that touchdown catches made by Jeremy Shockey and Amani Toomer should not have been ruled completions.
On Sunday, with 1 minute 14 seconds left in the second quarter and the Seahawks leading, 7-3, Shockey caught a 7-yard pass from Eli Manning in the center of the end zone. Seattle safety Marquand Manuel lowered his right shoulder into Shockey and forced the ball to the turf, though officials signaled a touchdown.
Jim Blackwood, the replay review official, asked Nemmers, an N.F.L. game official for 21 years, to review the play to determine if Shockey had possession long enough to constitute a catch. After a few moments, Nemmers emerged from under the hooded replay monitor and declared that Shockey had possession before losing the ball. The touchdown stood and the Giants took a 10-7 lead into halftime.
With 2:03 left in regulation, Toomer leaped high and caught a pass at the back of the end zone. He got his left foot down inside the end line, then appeared to drag the toes of his right shoe into his left as it hit the turf. Game officials concluded on the field that it was a touchdown - and Nemmers concurred after reviewing Holmgren's challenge.
That touchdown, and Shockey's subsequent 2-point conversion catch, tied the score at 21-21 with 1:59 left.
UPDATE: Wasn't this the same official that gave Testaverde the "phantom touchdown" in 2002?